嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
卆卆弌傍 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

proposed roads to freedom(宥吏徭喇岻揃)-及11何蛍

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




to   be   a   Russian   Government   agent   and   one   of   those   responsible   for   the 

recent   arrest   of   Poles。   Bakunin�察  �of   course�察  �repudiated   the   charge�察  �and 

George      Sand    wrote    to  the   ``Neue    Rheinische      Zeitung��''   denying     this 

statement in   toto。 The   denials were published by  Marx�察�and   there   was   a 

nominal reconciliation�察�but from this time onward there was never any real 

abatement of the hostility between these rival leaders�察�who did not meet 

again until 1864。 

     Meanwhile�察�the reaction had been everywhere gaining ground。 In May�察�

1849�察�an insurrection in Dresden for a moment made the revolutionaries 

masters     of   the   town。    They    held   it  for  five   days    and   established     a 

revolutionary   government。   Bakunin   was   the   soul   of   the   defense   which 

they made against the Prussian troops。 But they were overpowered�察�and at 

last   Bakunin     was    captured    while    trying   to  escape    with   Heubner      and 

Richard      Wagner�察    �the   last  of   whom�察    �fortunately     for  music�察   �was    not 

captured。 

     Now     began     a  long   period    of  imprisonment       in  many     prisons    and 

various countries。 Bakunin was sentenced to death on the 14th of January�察�

1850�察  �but    his   sentence    was   commuted       after   five  months�察  �and    he   was 

delivered over to Austria�察�which claimed the privilege of punishing him。 

The Austrians�察�in their turn�察�condemned him to death in May�察�1851�察�and 

again his sentence was commuted to imprisonment for life。 In the Austrian 

prisons he had fetters on hands and feet�察�and in one of them he was even 



                                                33 


´ Page 34´

                              PROPOSED ROADS TO FREEDOM 



chained to the wall by the belt。 There seems to have been some peculiar 

pleasure to be derived from the punishment of Bakunin�察�for the   Russian 

Government in its turn demanded him of the Austrians�察�who delivered him 

up。 In Russia he was confined�察�first in the Peter and Paul fortress and then 

in the Schluesselburg。 There be suffered from scurvy and all his teeth fell 

out。    His   health    gave    way    completely�察    �and    he  found     almost    all  food 

impossible   to   assimilate。   ``But�察  �if   his   body   became   enfeebled�察  �his   spirit 

remained inflexible。 He feared one thing above all。 It was to find himself 

some   day   led�察  �by   the   debilitating   action   of   prison�察  �to   the   condition   of 

degradation of which Silvio Pellico offers a well´known type。 He feared 

that   he   might   cease   to   hate�察  �that   he   might   feel   the   sentiment   of   revolt 

which upheld him becoming extinguished in his hearts that he might come 

to pardon his persecutors and resign himself to his fate。 But this fear was 

superfluous�察�his energy did not abandon him a single day�察�and he emerged 

from his cell the same man as when he entered。''��14�А�

       ��14�А�Ibid。 p。 xxvi。 

       After   the   death   of   the   Tsar   Nicholas   many   political   prisoners   were 

amnested�察  �but   Alexander   II   with   his   own   hand   erased   Bakunin's   name 

from the list。 When Bakunin's mother succeeded in obtaining an interview 

with the new Tsar�察�he said to her�察 �`Know�察�Madame�察�that so long as your 

son   lives�察  �he   can   never   be   free。''   However�察  �in   1857�察  �after   eight   years   of 

captivity�察�he was sent to the comparative freedom of Siberia。 From there�察�

in 1861�察�he succeeded in escaping to Japan�察�and thence through America to 

London。   He   had   been   imprisoned   for   his   hostility   to   governments�察  �but�察�

strange   to   say�察  �his   sufferings   had   not   had   the   intended   effect   of   making 

him   love   those   who   inflicted   them。   From   this   time   onward�察  �he   devoted 

himself     to  spreading      the  spirit  of   Anarchist     revolt�察  �without�察   �however�察�

having   to   suffer   any   further   term   of   imprisonment。   For   some   years   he 

lived in Italy�察�where he founded in 1864 an ``International Fraternity'' or 

``Alliance      of  Socialist    Revolutionaries。''      This   contained     men     of  many 

countries�察     �but   apparently      no   Germans。       It  devoted      itself  largely    to 

combating Mazzini's nationalism。 In 1867 he moved to Switzerland�察�where 

in the following year he helped to found the ``International Alliance of So´ 

cialist Democracy��'' of which he drew up the program。 This program gives 



                                                 34 


´ Page 35´

                              PROPOSED ROADS TO FREEDOM 



a good succinct resume of his opinions�此�

       The Alliance declares itself atheist�察�it desires the definitive and entire 

abolition   of   classes   and   the   political   equality   and   social   equalization   of 

individuals of both sexes。 It desires that the earth�察�the instrument of labor�察�

like   all   other   capital�察  �becoming   the   collective   property   of   society   as   a 

whole�察�shall be no longer able to be utilized except by the workers�察�that is 

to   say�察  �by   agricultural   and   industrial   associations。   It   recognizes   that   all 

actually   existing   political   and   authoritarian   States�察  �reducing   themselves 

more and more to the mere administrative functions of the public services 

in their respective countries�察�must disappear in the universal union of free 

associations�察�both agricultural and industrial。 

       The International Alliance of Socialist Democracy desired to become 

a branch of the International Working Men's Association�察�but was refused 

admission       on   the  ground     that  branches     must    be   local�察  �and   could    not 

themselves be international。 The Geneva group of the Alliance�察�however�察�

was admitted later�察�in July�察�1869。 

     The   International   Working   Men's   Association   had   been   founded   in 

London   in   1864�察  �and   its   statutes   and   program   were   drawn   up   by   Marx。 

Bakunin at first did not expect it to prove a success and refused to join it。 

But it spread with remarkable rapidity in many countries and soon became 

a great power for the propagation of Socialist ideas。 Originally it was by 

no means wholly Socialist�察�but in successive Congresses Marx won it over 

more     and    more    to   his  views。     At   its  third   Congress�察    �in   Brussels    in 

September�察      �1868�察   �it  became     definitely    Socialist。    Meanwhile       Bakunin�察�

regretting his earlier abstention�察�had decided to join it�察�and he brought with 

him   a   considerable   following   in   French´Switzerland�察  �France�察  �Spain   and 

Italy。   At   the   fourth   Congress�察    �held   at  Basle    in  September�察     �1869�察   �two 

currents were strongly marked。 The Germans and English followed Marx 

in his belief in the State as it was to become after the abolition of private 

property�察�they followed him also in his desire to found Labor Parties in the 

various     countries�察   �and    to  utilize   the  machinery      of   democracy      for   the 

election o* representatives of Labor to Parliaments。 On the other hand�察�the 

Latin   nations   in   the   main   followed   Bakunin   in   opposing   the   State   and 

disbelieving in the machinery of representative government。 The conflict 



                                                 35 


´ Page 36´

                             PROPOSED ROADS TO FREEDOM 



between these two groups grew more and more bitter�察�and each accused 

the other of various offenses。 The statement that Bakunin was a spy was 

repeated�察     �but   was    withdrawn      after   investigation。     Marx     wrote    in   a 

confidential   communication   to   his   German   friends   that   Bakunin   was   an 

agent of the Pan´Slavist party and received from them 25��000 francs a year。 

Meanwhile�察�Bakunin became for a time interested in the attempt to stir up 

an agrarian revolt in Russia�察�and this led him to neglect the contest in the 

International      at  a   crucial    moment。      During     the  Franco´Prussian        war 

Bakunin passionately took the side of France�察�especially after the fall of 

Napoleon       III。  He    endeavored      to   rouse    the   people    to   revolutionary 

resistance like that of 1793�察�and became involved in an abortive attempt at 

revolt   in   Lyons。   The   French   Government   accused   him   of   being   a   paid 

agent of Prussia�察�and it was with difficulty that he escaped to Switzerland。 

The dispute with Marx and his followers had become exacerbated by the 

national   dispute。   Bakunin�察  �like   Kropotkin   after   him�察  �regarded   the   new 

power of Germany as the greatest menace to liberty in the world。 He hated 

the Germans with a bitter hatred�察�partly�察�no doubt�察�on account of Bismarck�察�

but proba
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��1�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��