嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
卆卆弌傍 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

she stands accused(慢頁瓜御)-及6何蛍

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




`queens'   and   other   honorifics   in   application   to   the   lost   men   and   women 

with     whom     such    works     must    treat。   There     is  no   romance      in   crime。 

Romance   is   life   gilded�察  �life   idealized。      Crime   is   never   anything   but   a 

sordid business�察�demonstrably poor in reward to its practitioners。 

     But�察�sordid or not�察�crime has its human interest。                 Its practitioners are 

still   part   of   life�察  �human   beings�察  �different   from   law´abiding   humanity   by 

God´alone´knows´what freak of heredity or kink in brain convolution。                            I 

will   not   ask   the   reader�察  �as   an   excuse   for   my  book�察 �to   view  the   criminal 

with the thought attributed to John Knox�此�

     ``There�察  �but   for   the   Grace   of   God�察  �goes   ''    Because   the   phrase 

might     as   well    be   used   in   contemplation       of   John    D。   Rockefeller      or 

Augustus John or Charlie Chaplin or a man with a wooden leg。                          I do not 

ask that you should pity these women with whom I have to deal�察�still less 

that you should contemn them。                Something between the two will serve。 



                                                  18 


´ Page 19´

                             SHE STANDS ACCUSED 



I write the book because I am interested in crime myself�察�and in the hope 

that you'll like the reading as much as I like the writing of it。 



                                         19 


´ Page 20´

                                 SHE STANDS ACCUSED 



             II。 A FAIR NECK FOR THE 

                                  MAIDEN 



     In   her   long   history   there   can   have   been   few   mornings   upon   which 

Edinburgh had more to offer her burghers in the way of gossip and rumour 

than on that of the 1st of July�察�1600。          In this `gate' and that `gate��' as one 

may     imagine�察   �the  douce    citizens   must    have   clustered    and   broke   and 

clustered�察�like eddied foam on a spated burn。            By conjecture�察�as they have 

always been a people apt to take to the streets upon small occasion as on 

large�察�it is not unlikely that the news which was to drift into the city some 

thirty´five   days   laternamely�察  �that   an   attempt   on   the   life   of   his   Sacred 

Majesty�察�the High   and Mighty  ��and Rachitic��  Prince�察�James   the Sixth of 

Scotland�察    �had   been    made    by   the  brothers    Ruthven     in  their  castle  of 

Gowrieit is not unlikely that the first buzz of the Gowrie affair caused no 

more stir�察�for the time being at any rate�察�than the word which had come to 

those   Edinburgh   folk   that   fine   morning   of   the   first   day   in   July。 The 

busier   of   the   bodies   would   trot   from  knot   to   knot�察  �anxious   to   learn   and 

retail the latest item of fact and fancy regarding the tidings which had set 

tongues going since the early hours。           Murder�察�no less。 

     If the contemporary juridical records�察�even what is left of them�察�be a 

criterion�察   �homicide     in  all  its  oddly   named     forms    must    have   been    a 

commonplace to those couthie lieges of his Slobberiness�察�King Jamie。                     It 

is hard to believe that murder�察�qua murder�察�could have been of much more 

interest to them than the fineness of the weather。            We have it�察�however�察�on 

reasonable authority�察�that the murder of the Laird of Warriston did set the 

people of ``Auld Reekie'' finely agog。 

     John Kincaid�察�of Warriston�察�was by way of being one of Edinburgh's 

notables。     Even   at   that   time   his   family   was   considered   to   be   old。 He 

derived   from   the   Kincaids   of   Kincaid�察  �in   Stirlingshire�察  �a   family   then   in 

possession of large estates in that county and here and there about Lothian。 

His own property of Warriston lay on the outskirts of Edinburgh itself�察�just 

above a mile from Holyroodhouse。               Notable among his possessions was 

one   which   he   should�察  �from   all   accounts�察  �dearly   have   prized�察  �but   which 



                                               20 


´ Page 21´

                                  SHE STANDS ACCUSED 



there are indications he treated with some contumely。                 This was his wife�察�

Jean   Livingstone�察  �a   singularly   beautiful   girl�察  �no   more   than   twenty´one 

years of age at the time when this story opens。                Jean�察�like her husband�察�

was a person of good station indeed。             She was a daughter of the Laird of 

Dunipace�察 �John   Livingstone�察 �and   related   through   him  and   her  mother   to 

people of high consideration in the kingdom。 

     News of the violent death of John Kincaid�察�which had taken place soon 

after    midnight�察   �came     quickly    to  the   capital。   Officers     were    at  once 

dispatched。      Small     wonder     that   the  burghers    found    exercise    for  their 

clacking tongues from the dawning�察�for the lovely Jean was taken by the 

officers   `red´hand��'   as   the   phrase   was�察  �for   the   murder   of   her   husband。 

With her to Edinburgh�察�under arrest�察�were brought her nurse and two other 

servingwomen。 

     To Pitcairn�察�compiler of Criminal Trials in Scotland�察�from indications 

in whose account of the murder I have been set on the hunt for material 

concerning it�察�I am indebted for the information that Jean and her women 

were   taken   red´hand。       But   I   confess   being   at   a   loss   to   understand   it。 

Warriston�察     �as   indicated�察   �stood    a  good    mile    from    Edinburgh。       The 

informant bringing word of the deed to town�察�even if he or she covered the 

distance on   horseback�察�must have   taken some   time  in getting   the  proper 

authorities     to  move。     Then     time   would    elapse    in  quantity    before   the 

officers dispatched could be at the house。             They themselves could hardly 

have   taken   the   Lady   Warriston   red´hand�察  �because   in   the   meantime   the 

actual perpetrator of the   murder�察�a   horse´boy named   Robert Weir�察 �in   the 

employ of Jean's father�察�had made good his escape。                 As a fact�察�he was not 

apprehended   until   some   time   afterwards�察  �and   it   would   seem�察  �from   the 

records given in the   Pitcairn Trials�察 �that it   was not   until   four   years   later 

that he was brought to trial。 

     A person taken red´hand�察�it would be imagined�察�would be one found in 

such circumstances relating to a murder as would leave no doubt as to his 

or her having ``airt and pairt'' in the crime。           Since it must have taken the 

officers    some    time   to  reach    the  house�察   �one   of  two   things   must    have 

happened。       Either some officious person or persons�察�roused by the killing�察�

which�察  �as   we   shall   see�察  �was   done   with   no   little   noise�察  �must   have   come 



                                                21 


´ Page 22´

                                  SHE STANDS ACCUSED 



upon Jean and her women immediately upon the escape of Weir�察�and have 

detained   all   four   until   the   arrival   of   the   officers�察  �or   else   Jean   and   her 

women must have remained by the dead man in terror�察�and have blurted 

out the truth of their complicity when the officers appeared。 

     Available records are irritatingly uninformative upon the arrest of the 

Lady Warriston。         Pitcairn himself�察  �in   1830�察�talks   of his   many  ``fruitless 

searches''   through   the   Criminal   Records         of   the   city   of   Edinburgh�察 �the 

greater   part   of   which   are   lost�察  �and   confesses   his   failure   to   come   on   any 

trace of the actual proceedings in this case�察�or in the case of Robert Weir。 

For    this  reason    the   same    authority    is  at  a  loss  to  know    whether     the 

prisoners were immediately put to the knowledge of an assize�察�being taken 

``red´hand��''   without   the   formality   of   being   served   a   ``dittay''   ��as   who 

should say an indictment���察�as in ordinary cases�察�before the magistrates of 

Edinburgh�察�or else sent for trial before the baron bailie of the regality of 

Broughton�察�in whose jurisdiction Warriston was situated。 

     It would perhaps heighten the drama of the story if it could be learned 

what   Jean   and   her   women   did   between   the   time   of   the   murder   and   the 

arrest。     It  would     seem�察   �however�察    �that  the   Lady    Warriston     had   some 

intention of taking flight with Weir。           One is divided between an idea that 

the horse´boy did not want to be hampered and that he was ready for self´ 

sacrifice。     ``You shall tarry still��'' we read that he said�察 �`and if this matter 

come not to light you shall say�察 �He died in the gallery��' and I s
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��