嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
卆卆弌傍 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

she stands accused(慢頁瓜御)-及14何蛍

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




is merely as strong as its weakest member。             Overbury had no approach to 

the King save through the King's favourite。            Rochester could have no real 

weight with the King�察�at least in affairs of State�察�except what he borrowed 

from Overbury。        Divided�察�the two were powerless。            No�察�more than that�察�

there had to be no flaw in their linking。 

     The   wily   Northampton�察  �one   may   be   certain�察  �was   fully   aware   of   this 

possible weakness in the combination opposed to his advancement。                       He 

would   be   fully  aware�察  �that   is�察 �that   it   was   there   potentially�察  �but   when   he 

began�察�as his activities would indicate�察�to work for the creation of that flaw 

in the relationship between Rochester and Overbury it is unlikely that he 

knew      the  flaw    had   already    begun    to  develop。      Unknown        to  him�察�

circumstance already had begun to operate in his favour。 

     Overbury was Rochester's tutor in more than appertained to affairs of 

State。    It is more than likely that in Carr's wooing of Lady Essex he had 

held the role of Cyrano de Bergerac�察�writing those gracefully turned letters 

and composing those accomplished verses which did so much to augment 

and give constancy to her ladyship's love for Rochester。                It is certain�察�at 

any    rate�察 �that  Overbury     was    privy   to  all  the  correspondence      passing 

between the pair�察�and that even such events as the supplying by Forman 

and Mrs Turner of that magic powder�察�and the Countess's use of it upon 

her husband�察�were well within his knowledge。 

     While   the   affair   between   his   alter   ego   and   the   Lady  Essex   might   be 

looked upon as mere dalliance�察�a passionate episode likely to wither with a 

speed equal to that of its growth�察�Overbury�察�it is probable�察�found cynical 



                                              45 


´ Page 46´

                                   SHE STANDS ACCUSED 



amusement in helping it on。            But when�察�as time went on�察�the lady and her 

husband      separated     permanently�察     �and    from    mere    talk  of   a  petition   for 

annulment of the Essex marriage that petition was presented in actual form 

to   the   King�察    �Overbury      saw    danger。     Northampton         was    backing     the 

petition。     If it succeeded Lady Essex would be free to marry Rochester。 

And the marriage�察�since Northampton was not the man to give except in 

the expectation of plenty�察�would plant the unwary Rochester on the hearth 

of his own and Overbury's enemies。               With Rochester in the Howard camp 

there    would     be   short   shrift  for   Thomas      Overbury。      There     would     be�察�

though   Rochester   in   his   infatuation   seemed   blind   to   the   fact�察  �as   short   a 

shrift as the Howards could contrive for the King's minion。 

     In that march of inevitability which marks all real tragedy the road that 

is   followed   forks   ever   and   again   with   an   `if。'  And   we   who�察  �across   the 

distance of time�察�watch with a sort of Jovian pity the tragic puppets in their 

folly   miss   this   fork   and   that   fork   on   their   road   of   destiny   select�察  �each 

according   to   our   particular   temperaments�察  �a   particular   `if'   over   which   to 

shake our heads。         For me�察�in this story of Rochester�察�Overbury�察�Frances 

Howard�察�and the rest�察�the point of tragedy�察�the most poignant of the issues�察�

is   the   betrayal   by   Robert   Carr   of   Overbury's   friendship。        Though   this 

story is essentially�察�or should be�察�that of the two women who were linked 

in fate with Rochester and his coadjutor�察�I am constrained to linger for a 

moment on that point。 

     Overbury's counsel had made Carr great。                  With nothing but his good 

looks   and   his personal  charm�察 �his   only  real   attributes�察 �Carr  had been   no 

more     than    King    James's    creature。     James�察    �with    all  the  pedantry�察    �the 

laboured   cunning�察  �the   sleezy   weaknesses   of   character   that   make   him   so 

detestable�察�was yet too shrewd to have put power in the hands of the mere 

minion that Carr would have been without the brain of Overbury to guide 

him。     Of   himself   Carr   was   the   `toom   tabard'   of   earlier   parlance   in   his 

native  country�察  �the   `stuffed   shirt'   of   a   later  and   more   remote   generation。 

But beyond the coalition for  mutual help that existed between   Overbury 

and   Carr�察  �an   arrangement   which   might   have   thrived   on   a   basis   merely 

material�察�there was a deep and splendid friendship。                  `Stuffed shirt' or not�察�

Robert   Carr   was   greatly   loved   by   Overbury。         Whatever   Overbury   may 



                                                 46 


´ Page 47´

                                 SHE STANDS ACCUSED 



have thought of Carr's mental attainments�察�he had the greatest faith in his 

loyalty as a friend。      And here lies the terrible pity in that `if' of my choice。 

The love between the two men was great enough to have saved them both。 

It broke on the weakness of Carr。 

     Overbury   was   aware   that�察  �honestly   presented�察  �the   petition   by   Lady 

Essex for the annulment of her marriage had little chance of success。                  But 

for the obstinacy of Essex it might have been granted readily enough。                   He 

had�察�however�察�as we have seen�察�forced her to live with him as his wife�察�in 

appearance at least�察�for several months in the country。               There now would 

be    difficulty   in  putting    forward    the   petition   on   the  ground     of  non´ 

consummation of the marriage。 

     It  was�察  �nevertheless�察    �on  this  ground     that  the  petition   was   brought 

forward。      But the non´consummation was not attributed�察�as it might have 

been�察 �to   the   continued separation   that   had begun   at   the  altar�察  �the   reason 

given     was    the   impotence      of   the   husband。       Just    what    persuasion 

Northampton   and   the   Howards   used   on   Essex   to   make   him   accept   this 

humiliating implication it is hard to   imagine�察�but by the   time   the   coarse 

wits    of  the  period    had   done   with   him   Essex    was    amply    punished    in 

ridicule for his primary obstinacy。 

     Sir   Thomas   Overbury�察  �well   informed   though   he   usually   was�察  �must 

have been   a good   deal in the dark   regarding the negotiations which had 

brought the nullity suit to this forward state。            He had warned Rochester 

so frankly of the danger into which the scheme was likely to lead him that 

they   had   quarrelled   and   parted。     If   Rochester   had   been   frank   with   his 

friend�察�if�察�on the ground of their friendship�察�he had appealed to him to set 

aside his prejudice�察�it might well have been that the tragedy which ensued 

would     have    been   averted。     Enough      evidence     remains    to  this  day   of 

Overbury's kindness for Robert   Carr�察�there is enough   proof of the  man's 

abounding resource and wit�察�to give warrant for belief that he would have 

had the will�察�as he certainly had the ability�察�to help his friend。              Overbury 

was     one   of   the  brightest    intelligences    of   his   age。   Had      Rochester 

confessed the extent of his   commitment with Northampton there is  little 

doubt     that   Overbury     could    and    would    have    found    a  way    whereby 

Rochester      could    have    attained   his   object   ��of  marriage     with   Frances 



                                               47 


´ Page 48´

                                 SHE STANDS ACCUSED 



Howard���察�and this without jeopardizing their mutual power to the Howard 

menace。 

     In denying the man who had made him great the complete confidence 

which their friendship demanded Rochester took the tragically wrong path 

on   his   road   of   destiny。  But   the   truth   is   that   when   he   quarrelled   with 

Overbury       he   had   already    betrayed    the   friendship。     He     had   already 

embarked on the perilous experiment of straddling between two opposed 

camps。      It was an experiment that he�察�least of all men�察�had the adroitness 

to bring off。     He was never in such need of Overbury's brain as when he 

aligned himself in secret with Overbury's enemies。 

     It is entirely probable that in linking up with Northampton Rochester 

had   no   mind   to   injure   his   friend。  The   bait   was   the   woman   he   loved。 

Without Northampton's aid the nullity suit could not be put forward�察�and 

without the   annulment   there   could be   no   marriage   for   him  with   Frances 

Howard。       But he had no sooner joined with Northampton than the very 
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��